Israeli Government and Military Clash Over Gaza Camp Plan Amid Humanitarian Crisis

A dispute has emerged between the Israeli government and the military regarding the proposed construction of a camp for Palestinians in southern Gaza. This disagreement centers on the financial implications and potential consequences of the project. Former Prime Minister Ehud Olmert has criticized the plan, warning that it could resemble a "concentration camp."

The "humanitarian city" project has become a point of contention in ceasefire negotiations with Hamas. Israel aims to maintain a military presence in significant areas of Gaza, including the ruins of Rafah, where the camp is planned. Hamas, however, is advocating for a complete withdrawal. A senior Hamas member described the camp proposal as an attempt to obstruct negotiations, potentially complicating the peace process.

The camp is envisioned as an isolated area, with Palestinians confined between the Egyptian border and the Israeli military's "Morag corridor." Initially, the plan involves relocating 600,000 people, with the potential for the entire Gazan population to be moved there eventually. Residents would only be permitted to leave for another country.

The plan, which has the backing of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, has raised concerns among Israel's allies and within the country. Olmert's criticism, which drew comparisons to Nazi-era Germany, sparked strong reactions. The military has also expressed opposition to the project, despite being ordered to develop implementation plans.

Tensions escalated during a security cabinet meeting, with the IDF chief of staff clashing with Netanyahu. The military argued that the project would divert resources, hindering its operational capabilities and efforts to rescue hostages. Netanyahu reportedly criticized the presented plans as too costly and time-consuming, demanding a revised, more efficient timeline.

Financial objections to the "humanitarian city" plan have also been raised. The estimated annual cost of 15 billion shekels would significantly strain the state's budget, potentially impacting funding for essential services. Senior Israeli officials estimate the construction cost to be between $2.7 billion and $4 billion, with Israel initially bearing the majority of the expense.

The dispute coincides with ongoing Israeli strikes across Gaza, resulting in numerous casualties. Hospitals in various areas have reported fatalities, including children and women. Meanwhile, UN agencies have reiterated warnings about the critical fuel shortage, which threatens to halt essential services, including hospital operations, ambulance services, and vital infrastructure.