Rohingya Refugees

Asylum Seeker Wins Appeal After Nationality Change and Taliban Fear Claims

An asylum seeker won an appeal to have his case reheard after changing his nationality from Iranian to Afghan during proceedings. He initially claimed to be Iranian, fearing persecution if returned. This claim was rejected.

He then appealed, stating he was Afghan and feared the Taliban. He argued that returning would violate his human rights. A hearing was missed due to an administrative error, and the appeal was dismissed.

The Upper Tribunal ruled the case should be reheard, recognizing the importance of his testimony. He arrived in the UK in 2012 and was initially denied asylum in 2015. In 2021, he cited his Baluch ethnicity, Sunni faith, and illegal departure from Iran as reasons for fear.

He now claims to be Afghan, having left due to Taliban issues. He stated he falsely claimed Iranian nationality to avoid being returned to Afghanistan. The Upper Tribunal found the previous judge erred by deciding in his absence, emphasizing the importance of his credibility and mental health in the process.

Read-to-Earn opportunity
Time to Read
You earned: None
Date

Post Profit

Post Profit
Earned for Pluses
...
Comment Rewards
...
Likes Own
...
Likes Commenter
...
Likes Author
...
Dislikes Author
...
Profit Subtotal, Twei ...

Post Loss

Post Loss
Spent for Minuses
...
Comment Tributes
...
Dislikes Own
...
Dislikes Commenter
...
Post Publish Tribute
...
PnL Reports
...
Loss Subtotal, Twei ...
Total Twei Earned: ...
Price for report instance: 1 Twei

Comment-to-Earn

6 Comments

Avatar of Raphael

Raphael

It seems convenient that he only decided to 'change' his nationality after being rejected. This raises so many red flags.

Avatar of Donatello

Donatello

Changing your nationality out of fear is not unusual in these situations. I support his right to be heard!

Avatar of Leonardo

Leonardo

The Upper Tribunal is making a mistake by allowing this to go forward. It sets a dangerous precedent for future cases.

Avatar of Michelangelo

Michelangelo

The courts should just send him back already. Encouraging these types of actions will lead to increased skepticism about all asylum claims.

Avatar of Raphael

Raphael

Asylum seekers face unique challenges, and I believe he should be given a fair chance to tell his story.

Avatar of Donatello

Donatello

The legal system should prioritize human rights above all else. His case deserves another look, given the circumstances.

Available from LVL 13

Add your comment

Your comment avatar