Nelson Divided Over Proposal for Australia's Tallest Wind Turbines

Wind farm proposal sparks debate in Nelson

Residents and holiday home owners in the south-west Victorian town of Nelson are divided over a proposal to build the equal-tallest wind turbines in Australia among local pine plantations.

The project, known as the Kentbruck Green Power Hub, is being proposed by Neoen, a renewable energy company. The wind farm would consist of 105 turbines, each standing at 270 meters tall.

Concerns over visual impact and environment

Some residents are concerned about the visual impact of the turbines, arguing that they would detract from the picturesque landscape. Others are worried about the potential impact on the environment, particularly on birds and bats.

"They impose on the landscape to a significant degree," said Nelson resident Fran Thompson. "If you're interested in wild places, if you're interested in threatened species, it's an affront."

Neoen's response

Neoen argues that the turbines will be located in a commercial pine plantation with relatively few residents nearby. The company also says that the height of the turbines will help to minimize their impact on birds and bats.

"The minimum blade tip height of the turbines was adjusted from 45 meters above ground level to 60 meters following careful consideration of the local ecology," said Neoen Victoria state leader Alicia Webb.

Support from some sectors

The Committee for Portland, which represents the largest employers in the city, has expressed support for the project. The committee argues that the wind farm will create jobs and support the ongoing operation of Portland's aluminium smelter.

"The reality is these are being constructed in a monoculture – in a pine plantation predominantly – and most people aren't actually in the pine plantation," said John Weichert, deputy chair of the Committee for Portland.

Consultation and decision-making

Consultation on the proposed wind farm is currently underway, with the public invited to submit their feedback to the Victoria Department of Planning and Transport. The final decision on whether to approve the project will be made by the Victorian government.