Surrey's $1.3M Legal Fight Over Police Raises Cost, Decision Questions

Surrey's Legal Battle Against Police Transition Cost Nearly $1.3 Million

The City of Surrey in British Columbia spent nearly $1.3 million on a legal battle against the province's order to complete its transition from the RCMP to a local police force. The lawsuit, ultimately unsuccessful, challenged the Solicitor-General's authority to mandate the transition and the constitutionality of related changes to the Police Act.

External lawyers billed the city a total of $1,283,065.99 for the failed judicial review. Additionally, Mayor Brenda Locke and her staff expensed over $900 for meals and transportation related to court proceedings. The total cost of the legal battle, including staff time and other expenses, is likely significantly higher.

This expenditure comes amidst ongoing controversy surrounding the transition. Mayor Locke, who campaigned on reversing the move, argues that the court challenge helped secure a $250 million agreement with the province to offset the higher costs of the Surrey Police Service. However, critics argue that the province offered a similar deal before the lawsuit, making the legal battle a waste of taxpayer money.

The cost of the legal fight also raises questions about the mayor's decision-making and use of public funds, especially considering the transition appeared inevitable. Political analysts suggest that the lawsuit may have been motivated by a desire to avoid appearing pressured by the province rather than by genuine concerns about the transition's cost.

The Surrey Police Service is now set to be fully operational on November 29, 2024, marking the largest shift of its kind in Canadian history. The transition remains a contentious issue, with ongoing debate about its cost-effectiveness and impact on public safety.